Is Lena Dunham Saying Fuck You to Critics Who Called Her Racist?

01/11/2013 12:35 PM |

This is definitely not a Fuck you, haters.
  • indiewire.com
  • “This is definitely not a ‘Fuck you, haters.'”

No. She’s not. Or at least that’s what Dunham claims in an interview she did with New York Magazine. When asked whether or not the fact that she appears naked and straddling actor Donald Glover within the first few minutes of the season premiere is a nod to the critiques that the Girls cast is monochromatic in a way that doesn’t reflect the population of Brooklyn, Dunham responded, “It definitely wasn’t a ‘Fuck you, haters!’ That’s not really how I tend to roll my game.” Cool. So that’s settled then? Dunham is not saying “Fuck you.” She doesn’t roll that way. Except, wait.

Dunham continues on to say, “at the same time, it [casting Glover] was a pretty clear statement that we are comfortable, that there isn’t a political agenda against having black characters in the show.” Well, I’m certainly glad that’s settled. In sum, Lena Dunham isn’t racist because her character sleeps with a black guy. This is certainly—without a doubt—how you know that someone isn’t racist. Personally, I didn’t realize that I wasn’t anti-Semitic until I married an Israeli. Then it was all, oh, cool! Haters can go fuck themselves, because look who I sleep with at night.

Anyway, I never really jumped on the whole “Girls is racist” bandwagon because, well, society is racist and it’s segregated in the places where we don’t expect it to be. There are plenty of young, white women in New York who have little to no interaction with people of different races or, for that matter, economic backgrounds. It’s sort of shitty and ridiculous and not really the norm but also not some wild exception. I guess what I’m saying is that it would be pretty cool if the world was perfect, but even if it was, do we really need our tv shows to be perfect too?

Actually, what is perhaps more notable than the fact that Dunham and Glover are an interracial couple is the news that Glover’s character is also a Republican. Which, gross. Also, TOTALLY unrealistic. There is no way any self-respecting young Brooklyn woman would ever date a Republican. Dunham even says that her character, Hannah, “doesn’t really have a clear sense of why you shouldn’t date a Republican; it’s kind of just like the same reason why you shouldn’t date a Nazi: You just shouldn’t.” And Dunham is mostly correct except that, really, most Republicans are worse than most Nazis. Not all Nazis, mind you. But most.

3 Comment

  • Since I’m not the dad of a young girl I could care less about Taylor Swift’s immature spiteful, vindictive little songs. Meanwhile, Katy Perry is hot. But that’s all I’ve got on her.

  • I think what got the racist band wagon going on was that GIRLS is a show compared to shows that were about the Brooklyn-hipster scene like “How To Make It In America”, “I Just Want My Pants Back”, and even “Bored To Death”( but that show had relevant interactions with people of color). Plus GIRLS would mostly be followed by people who live in North Brooklyn. So Lena set her self for a tough crowd.
    So true enough there are pockets of white of girls in NYC that have little or any intimate social interaction with people of color. But what got the racist band wagon going was that the white girls of North Brooklyn, LES, & lower Manhattan were the most likely group of white girls that would have meaningful social or sexual relations with people of color than lets say girls from the UWS, UES, & Murray Hill.
    Anecdotally speaking, I have seen more interracial heterosexual couples in Brooklyn than the city & most recently where its more than just black guy/white girl or white guy/asian girl but even asian guy/white girl or hispanic guy/white girl has made its visible presence in Brooklyn. But I do see how these combinations work only if they are a common economic-educated class. More likely two artist would be dating each other as oppose to an artist dating an electrician(not impossible but unlikely)

  • girls. black people. lena dunham. one of these things is not like the other. um yea: http://ryanmega.wordpress.com/2013/01/22/t…