| NOVEMBER 19-25

The Technology Issue
THE L’S BEST! (AND WORST) OF NYC

  
Brooke Ismach

As freedom-loving lovers of democracy and voting and stuff, we thought we’d try it out ourselves. We didn’t quite have the budget for nation building (hey, who does?) so we set up the inaugural L Magazine Best of New York City Readers’ Poll. That’s right, a poll for the people by the people, kind of about the people — needless to say, democracy is an ugly business. Oh yeah, one more thing: Mission Accomplished!

The People

New Yorker Closest to Sainthood: Reverend Billy
You seemed to like this downtown, countercultural mainstay; bizarrely, you also seemed to like Mariah Carey. Our favorite response: “The two women who escorted me off the train today when I almost passed out.”

New Yorker Closest to Hell: Michael Bloomberg
Hands down, without a doubt, it’s old Mikey. All the usual suspects showed up here: Paris, Rudy, The Donald, Ratner, and even Robert Moses (who’s already down there).

Most Desirable Woman: La Hillary Clinton
Wow, overwhelmingly. We didn’t think power was that sexy. Sweetest response: “Jenny.” Awww.

Most Desirable Man: Elvis Costello
WTF!? This is why we love our readers. Or at least that one Elvis-obsessed reader.

Most Irritating Personality:
A tie: Hipsters, Michael Musto
The snide, ironic commentary pretty much writes itself. Most confusing response: “Fakeness.”

Sexiest Newscaster:
Man: Matt Lauer
Woman: Kaity Tong
We offered to buy these two a luxury night on the town. Interestingly, only one of them declined… Can you guess who?

     


Best Drag Performer: Peppermint Gummybear
In a candy-coated landslide. Surprise contender: Donald Trump (gee, you people are funny).

Worst Drag Performer: Sherry Vine
Oddly enough, the voting here was disturbingly similar to the category above; except for the very strong showing from Al Sharpton.

Best Graffiti Artist: Neckface
Yeah, no kidding. Nearly tripled the number of votes for “The guy who tagged my building.” Evidently this category could also have been called, Name a Graffiti Artist.

Most Overexposed Celebrity: Paris Hilton
This one felt like a Byelorussian presidential election. The woman received nearly 96 percent of the vote, decimating the runners-up Olsen twins.

Best Reclusive NYC Celebrity: Woody Allen
When you think about it, he’s not really that reclusive… But we guess that’s democracy. Strangest response: Ed Koch. Ed Koch!

Most Missed New Yorker: JFK Jr.
Going through this one made us sad, like those Oscar death montages. Here are some more votes (cue music): Arthur Miller, Susan Sontag, Joe DiMaggio, Biggie Smalls, John Lennon, Frank Sinatra, Joey Ramone. Sigh.

The Places

Best Park
Tompkins Square
Which also recently made the “top-five dog runs” list in Dog Run Illustrated (or DogWorld or Transworld Dog or Dogger or something.) We feel kind of warm and downtown proud that you didn’t pick Central Park.

Fanciest Bathroom Experience
Waldorf Astoria, 301 Park Ave
The voting in this category seemed to have two themes: 1) The actual fixtures and atmosphere, and 2) The quality of the extracurricular activities. If you know what we mean...

Filthiest Bathrooms
Rothko, 116 Suffolk St.
A hotly contended race, with standards Port Authority and the Hole narrowly missing out on the top prize.

Best People-Watching Spot
The Union Square Steps
But are the people watching you? Probably not.

Best Non-Bar Pickup Spot
Whole Foods, 4 Union Square South
Is this arugula or kale? Are those real? Best response: “Times Square... just look for anyone staring up at the buildings.” And what? Surreptiously molest them?

Best Place for Napping
Central Park
Finally, a win for the big C.P. Other notable contenders: my desk, under my office desk, work, my office chair. Worst response: my bed.

Best Tourist Thing To Do Even If You’re Not A Tourist
Walking across the Brooklyn Bridge
Even when you were given express license to assume the mindset of a tourist, you had to be cool and not say things like “Times Square” or “go to the top of the Empire State Building.” Which is why we like you.

Best Tree-Lined Block
Jane Street
See Jane grow leafy. See Jane change color. See Jane and wish you had a much better job.

Best Street Fair
San Gennaro
Yeah, no shit. It is pretty fun isn’t it? Best response from a belligerent drunk: “None! They’re all nasty, except maybe the one where they sell Guinness… some Irish festival…” By the way, thanks for all the swell press releases!

Best Summer Day Trip
Coney Island
Followed at a close second by Central Park. You guys are soooo Downtown.

Best Building
The Chrysler Building
One of our staffers is literally in love with the beautiful, shining Chrysler. He talks about it all the time and when someone finally asked, “Well why don’t you marry it?”, his eyes just glazed over with quiet longing. It was pretty freaky.

Best Place to Have Public Sex
At the Beach
Sure, we were going for more specific advice on this one, but we understand. Best response: In that new CK billboard in Times Square.

The Food

Best 24-Hour Eats
Veselka, 144 Second Ave.
There is nothing better on a fiercely hot New York night, when the humidity has it feeling like 120 degrees, than a big steaming plate of cheese and potato pierogis. Kudos to Café L’Express for taking the non-diner, 24-hour crown.

Best Diner
Waverly Restaurant
385 Sixth Ave
Yeah, it is kind of classic. Excellent choice.

Best Brunch
Country Café, Soho

69 Thompson St.

Best Indian
Anywhere on 6th St.
Ok, we’re very disappointed with you for this one. So we’re no longer speaking to you, at least for the remainder of this blurb.

Best Italian
Aurora, Williamsburg

70 Grand St., Bklyn

Best Middle-Eastern
Bamiyan
, 358 Third Ave.
Wow, is Afghanistan technically in the Middle East? Yeah? Ok.

Best Thai
Spice Market, 403 W 13th St.
You guys may be a little too fancy for our blood.

Best Vietnamese
Vietnam Restaurant
, 369 Broome St.
We thought this place was a bit more of a secret… Clearly we’re shut ins.

Best Burger
Shake Shack

We get the feeling sometimes that this newish outdoor stand in Madison Square is like the shiny new character that turns up on teen dramas to initial adoration — and then turns out to be a psychopath. Not sure how an outdoor snack stand can be a psychopath though…

Best Fries
Pomme Frites
, 123 Second Ave.
Because, you know, that’s what their name means in French. And guess what? That shifty Shake Shack almost won this one too.

Best Pizza
Grimaldi’s
, 19 Old Fulton St, Bklyn
Also happens to be an office favorite. Most disappointing answer: Pizza Hut. Oh man.

Best Steak
Peter Luger
, 178 Broadway, Bklyn
The Harlem Globetrotters of steak polls.

     
Stef Weiss

Best Vegetarian
Counter
, 105 First Ave.
It’s slick and modern and doesn’t feel like you’re in an earnestly vegetarian restaurant. Which is good. Also across from McDonald’s, if you get hungry.

Best Restaurant to Take Your Parents
Peter Luger
, 178 Broadway, Bklyn
The old Best Steak/Where to Take Your Parents double up. Way to go, Pete.

The Nightlife

Hottest Bartender:

Chelsea:
Mr. Bruno
XL , 357 W 16th St.

East Village: Mr Antonio
The Cock, 29 Second Ave

LES: Mr. Divine
Pyramid, 101 Ave A

Meatpacking: Mr. Toto
Hell, 59 Gansevoort St.

West Village: Mr. Sanchez
Monster, 80 Grove St.
There is absolutely nothing wrong with a little ballot stuffing, especially if the stuffer is polite and uses honorifics.

Best Sleazy Dive
The Turkey’s Nest
(Williamsburg), 94 Bedford Ave, Bklyn
Did you know that the term “dive” comes from “diving bell” which was applied to early basement saloons that you had to walk down stairs to get to? It’s true. And it’s also true that the Turkey’s Nest is indeed a sleazy dive. For those of you who said Lit, we have nothing but scorn for your perception of the world.

Best Happy Hour
Verlaine
, 110 Rivington St.
Oh how wise you are gentle readers. Honestly, any happy hour that runs until 10 pm is truly happy. Well buy you a drink.

Best Jukebox
Library Bar
, 7 Ave A
Seriously bitchin. They also have a great card catalogue, some pretty foxy librarians and a rockin’ mimeograph machine. Get it? LOL!

Most Depressing Bar
Last Exit, 136 Atlantic Ave, Bklyn
Tacked onto the end of Atlantic Avenue (as it prepares to drown itself in the East River) this spot isn’t nearly as depressing as the Hubert Selby Jr. novel it’s named for, but we can understand why some people might find it a drag.

Best Dance Party
Lotus Sundays
, 409 W 14th St.
Every year, the number of “my house” votes seems to increase. One day, it just might win.

Best-Looking Clientele
Beauty Bar
, 231 E 14th St.
Wow, who knew a simple name had so much power. And for the doofus who voted for Coyote Ugly, we said clientele, not staff; and we said best looking.

Best Live Venue
Bowery Ballroom

6 Delancey St.
Totally kicked all the other venues’ asses. Have you ever actually watched a venue beat the shit of another venue? It’s awesome.

Best Gay Bar
Boysroom
, 9 Ave A
A relative newcomer to the East Village gay scene, this place is always filled with good, sleazy fun and plenty of go-go boys.

Worst Gay Bar
Duvet on Thursdays

45 W 21 St.
Our readers know that if you want to drink liquor in bed, it’s no better on satin sheets in Flatiron than in your airless East Village studio.

Best Lesbian Party Night
Barracuda
, 275 W 22nd St.
We bet that after hours, when the staff is cleaning up, they play that Heart song and rock out.

Best Gay Bar to Take Your Straight Friends
Bar 11
, 152 Orchard St.
Upstairs dancing, downstairs dancing. Boys and girls and Sophia Lamar. Not sure if this is a gay bar or not, but seems to fit the category nonetheless.

Best Comedy/Improv Troupe
Upright Citizens Brigade
, 307 W 26th St.
It’s like Saturday Night Live, only with jokes. And laughter.

     
Micheal Kravit

Best Burlesque Act
Julie Atlas Muz

You sure are an arty bunch of mothers aren’t you?

Best After Hours
Tie: Pink Elephant
, 73 Eighth Ave, Casbah Rouge, 2841 Broadway
Is there a name thing going here? Because you know rouge is French for red, and red is pretty close to pink…

Best Bar You Can Still Smoke In
Karma
, 51 First Ave.
Ah ha! One of the very few hookah bars in the city. You hippie motherfuckers.

Best Outdoor Patio
Bohemia Beer Garden
, 29-19 24th Ave, Astoria
Is a garden a patio? It is when a gazillion people vote for it.

Best Trivia Night
Pete’s Candy Store
, 709 Lorimer St, Bklyn
Because it’s so much fun being surrounded by people who are so much smarter than you are, and who enjoy taking every opportunity to make sure you know it.

Best Karaoke Night
Arlene’s Grocery

96 Stanton St.
You kids love that live rock ‘n’ roll karaoke. Honorable mention: Aireoke, air guitar wackiness at Trash.

For Locals Only

Best Train Station
Union Square

Frankly, we’re not sure why. And we don’t think you are either.

Worst Train Station
Canal St.

Because it’s sooo different from Union Square, right?

Best Train
The L

You love us! You really love us! (And the train with the similar sounding name to us.)

Worst Train
The F

Because F stands for failure.

Best NYC Blog Website
Gothamist

Take that Gawker. (Please don’t be mean to us again.)

Biggest NYC Myth
New Yorkers are mean

There were a lot of different answers for this, most of which were of the self-hating variety, e.g: NYC is cool. The weirdest answer: Being from New York will get you laid in your smallish, Midwestern hometown (as far as we’re concerned, that’s no myth).

Best Parade
Yankees

Been a while hasn’t it?

Worst Parade
A dead heat between the Puerto Rican Day and St. Patrick’s

Because evidently you’re all a bunch of early 19th-century xenophobic demagogues.

Most Important Local Issue
Development of the Brooklyn Rail Yards

Best Kept Secret
We’re Not Telling.

Because you might not be from New York.

Print | E-mail this article | Submit a Letter to the Editor

The Technology Issue
Everything Old Is... Still Here
Toys From the Future
Fare Is Fair
What Are You Thankful For?
Tips for Tips
What’s Your Favorite Thing About Thanksgiving?
Barstool Zeitgeist
Geneva Confection
Restaurant Review
Uncorked
The Conscientious Objector
Volunteer Army
Fashionville
Wolves in Sheepskin
Sex... With the Natural Redhead
Interference, Offense
Horoscope
Horoscope
Crossword
Tech Junkies
Tech Junkies ANSWERS


Oct 15

Oct 22

Oct 29
view entire archive

contact | site credits