Thursday, July 26, 2012

The Evolution of the New York Times Brooklyn Trend Piece

Posted by on Thu, Jul 26, 2012 at 10:20 AM

nty_building.jpg
As you may have noticed, the New York Times likes to write about Brooklyn. A lot. Really, a lot, a lot, a lot. Obviously this makes sense, since the Times is, after all, the paper of record for New York, and we are one big, sassy, z-snapping, news-making borough to contend with.

Unfortunately, as you also may have noticed, things really hit the skids here when it comes to the Brooklyn trend piece. So much so that it actually kind of seems like they're baiting us. Even after Brian Williams — representative of one of the biggest, most mainstream, New York-based media outlets around — publicly mocked the Times' "discovery of Brooklyn" as the biggest news story of 2010, no one took the hint.

No, they actually started doing it more. For every article that hits its target — Bushwick was a great real estate investment in 2006, beer brewing has seen a big renaissance in the area — there's another, earnestly chronicling everything from Greenpoint's inevitable transition into the "next Williamsburg" to the existence of bars and people with tattoos on Wythe avenue. It seems like the Times' infatuation with the curious, trendy young things of Brooklyn has only deepened, if not necessarily been returned.

Below, we take a look through some of Grey Lady's weirder love letters to our borough (or at least the newly hip parts), and we, uh, put our phones straight to silent:

Schwartz.png
September 10, 2006: Call It Booklyn

Summary: Writer, correctly, points out that a lot of famous authors reside in Brooklyn. Incorrectly, she seeks our collective sympathy that the competitive environment stresses her out. But oh, by the way, "I’m selling books, making film deals, moving copies in Germany." Just so you know.

Representative Quote: "Anywhere else in the country, people say, “Gee, you really published a book?” In Brooklyn, they ask when you’re going on Charlie Rose and if you know Jonathan Lethem. If not, end of conversation, time to move on. Getting off the F train right now is a young woman whose first novel was just pre-empted by Vintage for high six figures. The New York Times Magazine is writing her profile, Marion Ettlinger is taking her head shots, and she’s preapproved for a co-op on Prospect Park West."

Takeaway: Writing a trend piece about something you can't detach yourself from is just as dangerous as writing one about something you don't understand at all. Also, puns of the "Booklyn" sort should never be made. Except "Chilliamsburg," of course.


Rooooomies.jpg
  • Piotr Redlinski/The New York Times
February 11, 2007: You're Cool, But Can You Swing the Rent?

Summary: Apartment-hunters in Williamsburg are too focused on appearing cool, not focused enough on proving they can pay rent.

Representative Quote: "Robbie Stauder posted a short ad that mentioned, along with other basic information, his work as a television producer. He received about 50 responses (one signed “love”), most of them from people trying to break into his field. 'One guy sent me a music video he was in,' said Mr. Stauder, 30. 'It was this weird electro-dance European music with the guy carrying around an old milk jug. He found this girl and poured it on her.'

Takeaway: Show me a roommate horror story, and I'll show you five other people with one that's similar, and probably worse. Shitty New York roommates have always been, and always will be, the trend to end all trends.


Picture_1.png
  • Tony Cenicola/The New York Times
February 24, 2009: Brooklyn's New Culinary Movement

Summary: Following the rise of soon-to-be mainstays like Mast Brothers and Prime Meats, the Times looks at the flourishing, soon-to-be unbearable foodie movement as it manifests itself in Brooklyn.

Representative Quote: "These Brooklynites, most in their 20s and 30s, are hand-making pickles, cheeses and chocolates the way others form bands and artists’ collectives. They have a sense of community and an appreciation for traditional methods and flavors. They also share an aesthetic that’s equal parts 19th and 21st century, with a taste for bold graphics, salvaged wood and, for the men, scruffy beards."

Takeaway: We can't say they were wrong, but god, the tidings of overwrought things to come.


December 3, 2010: Destination: LAPTOPISTAN

Summary: You know how people make fun of the Times treating Brooklyn like a mysterious, quirky foreign entity? Constantly? That is literally what goes on here, as one author explores the fraught world of working in cafes on your laptop in a world he has dubbed "Laptopistan." If you listen closely, you can hear the angry tears of a thousand foreign war correspondents with each use of this newly made up word.

Representative Quote:
"A quick glance around shows I have brought my laptop, a month-old MacBook Pro, to its nesting ground. Diversity here means the odd white MacBook or old black PowerBook scattered amid the silver MacBook Pros. Throughout the week I will see only a handful of PCs, each looking sadly out of place, like they have arrived at a black-tie affair in a corduroy blazer."

Takeaway:
Privileged people in even the most vaguely creative industries really like to use Apple products and drink coffee, and like it better when other people are around to watch them do it.


CondoBaby.jpg
  • Robert Caplin/The New York Times
January 21, 2011: Williamsburg, Toddlertown

Summary: Williamsburg: not just for hipsters anymore. Now serving hipster parents with toddlers. In condos.

Representative Quote: "In August they moved into a $980,000 three-bedroom at 80 Metropolitan. Through his living-room window, Mr. Signer can see the Domino Sugar factory and the Williamsburg Bridge, partly obscured by the steel beams of new construction — just the industrial feel he wanted."

Takeaway:
A buzzed-about, up-and-coming neighborhood has gotten more expensive and attracted an older demographic. Tell me more!


ManBun.jpg
  • Mark Veltman/The New York Times
January 26, 2012: In Brooklyn, Committing to a Man Bun

Summary: Some men in Brooklyn — possibly elsewhere, too? — have decided to try to make buns happen.

Representative Quote: "Once you’ve committed to a man bun, how do you create one? Alexander Kellum, 31, a fine-arts painter and yoga teacher who lives in Williamsburg, bends forward and pulls his long chestnut hair in front of him; then he performs a twisting and wrapping motion until his hair is firmly tucked into a knot at the back of his head. Sometimes he’ll let a little hair poke out for an “abstract expressionist” flourish, he said. A rubber band, a hair band or even a piece of string holds his bun in place."

Takeaway: All style-related trends originate in Brooklyn, whether we want to be associated with them or not.


foodtruck.jpg
  • Ed Alcock/The New York Times

June 4, 2012: Food Trucks in Paris? U.S. Cuisine Finds Open Minds, and Mouths

Summary:
Ah, c'est magnifique! An opportunity to re-visit the origins of the immediately infamous phrase "très Brooklyn," first seen in this widely disputed piece on the burgeoning popularity of Brooklyn-esque food trucks en Paris.

Representative Quote: "In France, there is still a widespread belief that the daily diet in the United States consists of grossly large servings of fast food. But in Paris, American food is suddenly being seen as more than just restauration rapide. Among young Parisians, there is currently no greater praise for cuisine than 'très Brooklyn,' a term that signifies a particularly cool combination of informality, creativity and quality."

Takeaway:
People don't take too kindly to the use of "Brooklyn" as an adjective, particularly not the French, who also largely deny the popularity of food trucks. Mon dieu!


Biddies.jpg
  • Casey Kelbaugh/The New York Times
June 20, 2012: Rockaway Boardwalk as Catwalk

Summary:
A trip to the beach these days is another opportunity to feel bad about your outfit, because nothing is scared anymore.

Representative Quote:
"it’s only in New York on the way to the sole gorgeous sand strip in the world lying beneath the J.F.K. flight path that one will encounter a pack of smartly dressed women with full-sleeve tattoos who are volubly — and with their generation’s blithe disregard for social niceties — squawking at myna-bird speed about their shopping and money and boyfriend habits, and even more intimate things."

Takeaway:
These reporters have an unreal ability to find the very worst people, and get them to say the very worst things, while posing for pictures. We are all monsters.


July 19, 2012: All Roads Lead to Wythe Avenue


Summary:
Days after their discovery of late night diners, an investigation of bars, hotels, and galleries, some of which are located on Wythe avenue in Brooklyn. Need directions? They've got you covered.

Representative quote:
"Upstairs, a D.J. who resembled Jesus Christ played dub reggae, and when the sun crept below the jaw-dropping Manhattan skyline, it seemed to activate everyone’s internal Instagram clock. A sea of iPhones shot up to capture the blazing pink hues (#nofilter), as if the singer Grimes had just made a surprise appearance at a Skrillex concert."

Takeaway:
Williamsburg is really getting out of hand these days, but at least now there's a place for the parents and tourists to stay. Plus, the Times has hipped to the fact that "trés Brooklyn" is a phrase "so twee as to be routinely mocked." Progress?

Greenpoint.jpg
  • Uli Seit/The New York Times
July 22, 2012: Who You Calling Gritty?

Summary: Geez, this feels like a lot of talk about Williamsburg, doesn't it? Are you sick of it all, sick of yourself, sick of this world? No need to worry, because there's a new Williamsburg. It's Greenpoint!

Representative Quote: "No more bargain $8 haircuts, not even for dogs, though the local canines may have noticed the revamped sidewalks feel a tad smoother beneath their paws: gentrification is smoothing out all those hard edges."

Takeaway:
A year from now, you can safely expect another list like this, comprised entirely of articles about Greenpoint.

Follow Virginia K. Smith on Twitter @vksmith.

Tags: ,

More by Virginia K. Smith

Readers also liked…

Comments (3)

Showing 1-3 of 3

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-3 of 3

Add a comment

About The Author

Virginia K. Smith

Virginia K. Smith

Bio:
Virginia K. Smith is the Assistant Editor at The L Magazine and a Bushwick resident. Her profile picture was taken at Summerscreen, because she is a real team player.

Most Commented On

© 2013 The L Magazine
Website powered by Foundation