Friday, February 18, 2011

I Saw the Devil Lays its Vengeance Down Upon Thee This Weekend

Posted By on Fri, Feb 18, 2011 at 2:54 PM

Kim Ji-woon's I Saw the Devil screens this Sunday afternoon as part of Film Comment Selects, a sneak preview showing before IFC releases it on March 4.

I Saw the Devil, a proudly in-poor-taste thriller about predators playing with their food, opens on a serial killer who's a methodical madman—not unlike, you might say, the filmmakers, who plot their first act with the propulsive precision of expert pulp novelists; think Jim Thompson, or even Cormac McCarthy. The movie's first forty minutes or so—in which special agent and widower Soo-hyeon (Lee Byung-hun) pursues his fiancée's killer while the butcher, Kyung-Chul (Oldboy's Choi Min-sik), stalks fresh prey—is refreshingly efficient: emotional, but never indulgent; psychological, but only broadly, like an issue of Detective Comics. Its focus never strays from The Hunts, its pared-down, parallel procedurals—psychokiller and vigilante, not so much mouse and cat as cat and, um, bigger cat.

When the two converge, the opening act comes to a breathless close and I Saw the Devil devolves into gimmick: bereaved defeats bereaver but, instead of killing him, lets him go and tracks him from a distance. It's a sick game for both character and director: like the audience, Soo-hyeon follows this despicable cretin's adventures, but he also has the superpower of intervention, doing what the viewer never can—pop into the frame every time Kyung-Chul begins to hurt someone else and stop him. It lets director Kim (The Good, the Bad and the Weird) and his screenwriter Park Hoon-jung have it both ways: to revel in both villainy and its resulting heroism, to take glee in both the bad guy's lechery—indulging in the same misogyny that marred Na Hong-jin's The Chaser—and the good guy's sadistic retribution.

The filmmakers ditch efficiency for sensationalism. Mean-spiritedly long at 141 minutes, I Saw the Devil blends extraordinary gore with comedy both black and babyish: Kim is not above having his villain dig through his own diarrhea, or slip on scattered jacks like a Home Alone burglar. The director pretends, though, in regularly timed scenes of guilt-stricken anguish, that his message is still serious: that vengeance comes at a great cost. It's hard to take it seriously, though, when the director clearly relishes the good guy's righteous bloodbaths. At one point, the dead fiancée's sister tries to talk Soo-hyeon out of his obsession with retaliation. "This is pointless," she says. Agreed.

Tags: , , , , , ,


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

More by Henry Stewart

Most Commented On

Most Shared Stories

Top Viewed Stories

Top Topics in The Measure

Film (40)

Music (13)

Theater (13)

Special Events (11)

Art (9)

Books (3)

TV (3)

Politics (1)

Talks and Readings (1)

Media (1)

© 2014 The L Magazine
Website powered by Foundation