The Brooklyn Bar Awards 

sunburnt20120227_1343.jpg

Best Happy Hour Best Late Happy Hour Best Sports Bar
Best Beer Bar Best Themed Bar Best Cocktail Bar
Best Wine Bar Best Garden Best View
Best Spirits Best Free Drunk Snacks Best Karaoke Night
Best Dance Night Best Quiz Night Best Home Office
Best Bar to Bring a Parent Best Bar to Bring a Book Best Bar to Bring a Date
  Best Local  

 

Friendliest Staff:

The Sunburnt Calf

(611 Vanderbilt Ave, Prospect Heights)
The good-looking, good-timey Aussies at this new-ish outpost will greet you with a shot of passionfruit-infused tequila, keep the bottomless brunch drinks flowing, and expound enthusiastically about the kung fu movie clips on permanent loop behind the bar. They make enabling into an art form. (Photos by Crystal Gwyn)

sunburnt20120227_1351_new.jpg

sunburnt20120227_1366_new.jpg

sunburnt20120227_1375.jpg


Runner Up: Bar 718
(718 Fifth Ave, South Slope)
It's not that convenient for us to go to Bar 718; every time we try to get home, we pass out on the bus and the driver yells at us. So why do we keep coming back? Lots of reasons: the cozy interior, the random artsy movies silently projected huge on the wall, the kindness of the patrons. (Last time we were there, somebody was giving out back massages.) But most of all, it's the friendliness of the bartenders, who always make us feel like members of a community of tipplers, especially that cheerful long-haired fella who always remembers our drink, even though we can't remember his name (because he tells us when we're drunk!).

B61_bw.jpg

Best Happy Hour:

Strong Place

(270 Court St, Cobble Hill)
Two-dollar PBRs and dollar-off drafts are enticing happy hour draws. But this beer-centric bar and restaurant offers a deal more attuned to beer geeks: every weekday from 4-7pm, all 24 taps of craft beer are two for one. Where else can you get two Founders sweet and spicy Rye PA for just $5? Also, fresh oysters run $1 each during happy hour.

print_option.jpg


Runner Up: Brooklyn Ice House
(318 Van Brunt St, Red Hook)
All day, every day, the Ice House brings it home with sick food and shot & beer combos. Por ejemplo: the brass ring of this drinking life is, we’re sure, pulled pork paired with the Liberty: a bottle of Bud and a shot of Old Overholt $5. Come on, get happy.

bw.jpg

Best Late Happy Hour:

Minor Arcana

(706 Washington Ave, Prospect Heights)
Buy one draft at happy hour, and get a second one free by redeeming your buyback tarot card. After the night’s burlesque or dance or trivia event, the deal magically reappears between midnight and 2, when the weird little room reaches peak coziness.

minor_arcana-4.jpg


Runner Up: Abilene
(442 Court St, Carroll Gardens)
Abilene has been a home away from home for many an, um, editor at this magazine; it’s the kind of place you just seem to end up, way past your bedtime, the only one in the place, talking to the bartender about 90s indie rock. Hence, the midnight happy hour observed Sundays through Thursdays, perfect with their shamefully delicious snacks.

bw_2.jpg

Best Sports Bar:

Banter
(132 Havemeyer St, Williamsburg)
Whether you’re an expat, a recovering jock, or just brought back a couple Arsenal shot glasses from your junior abroad in London, this spacious footie bar is on target. The extensive beer selection leans toward crafts and imports, perfect accompaniment to the most artisanal of sports.

banter-feb.jpg


Runner Up: 200 Fifth
(200 Fifth Ave, Park Slope)
This Park Slope mainstay houses more flat-screen televisions (70) than one might have otherwise assumed the entire neighborhood did. And on every single one of them: a game! Sort of like the Applebee’s of your dreams.

bw.jpg

Best Beer Bar:

Matt Torrey’s
(46 Bushwick Ave, East Williamsburg)
With typically 15 or more New York beers on tap and 15 or so more mostly further-sourced labels in bottles, and all very fairly priced, Matt Torrey’s does an excellent job of proving that the best bars for beer aficionados aren’t necessarily those with twice as many taps or the most obscure selection—rather those specifically knowledgeable places that serve their rotation of brews fresh and right. Plus, just steps from the L for easy stumbling.

matttorreys2.jpg


Runner Up: Mary’s
(708 Fifth Ave, South Slope)
The draft selection here is good, though not spectacular; we recognize Mary’s for the quality of the beer itself. Think the condition of an establishment's tap lines doesn't matter? That's because you've never had beer that tasted this pristine. For example, you've never had a Sixpoint until you've had it from Mary's. Like, seriously—there are flavors you've never tasted.

bw.jpg

Best Cocktail Bar:

the Narrows
(1037 Flushing Ave, Bushwick)
Serving up a seasonably shifting range of classics like Old Fashioneds, Vieux Carrés and Milano-Torinos alongside genre-benders like the jala-piquant Que Bonita or the bourbon-barreled Derringer, the kind barkeeps at The Narrows know cocktail tradition, and tweak it with brio. Given their many great beers on hand and a fine wine list, too, as well as a large garden patio of topiary repute, you’ll soon forget how to drink elsewhere.

_MG_1819.jpg

_MG_2040.jpg


Runner Up: Henry Public
(329 Henry St, Cobble Hill)
The Taft-era suspenders are a bit much. But otherwise the general old timey-ness at this Cobble Hill cocktail den feels effortless and inviting. Expert cocktails are classic yet creative and make liberal use of potent elixirs like absinthe and smoky Islay Scotch.

adam_au_henry.jpg

Best Themed Bar:

Sycamore Bar & Flowershop
(1118 Cortelyou Road, Ditmas)
The vacation-quality backyard, live music, and crafting and mixology workshops ensure plenty of bustle at this neighborhood spot—even without the extra foot traffic around the quirky flower shop open most afternoons and evenings. Try the $10 Beer & Bouquet special. (Photos by John Hagan)

4843130179_675e0f61be_b.jpg

Picture-189.jpg

4843750090_9e23d5ef49_b.jpg


Runner Up: Ontario
(559 Grand St, Williamsburg)
Less a cluttered and overassertive memorabilia dump than an actual simulacrum: Moosehead on tap, dirt-cheap Black Velvet Whisky, and frankly gratuitous quantities of wood paneling. That the neighborhood is populated largely by beardy guys in sweatshirts with wolves on them also helps.

sam_horine_ontario.jpg

Best Wine Bar:

The Owl’s Head

(479 74th St, Bay Ridge)
Owned and operated by artists and aesthetes, Owl’s Head offers a formidable array of wines from the rustic and robust to the delicate and refined, and from the local to the extensively foreign—and their cheeses, panini and creative crostini are perfect for palate-titillating pairings therewith. The turquoise-specked maple bar is itself a beguiling work of art worth the trip. Is it one of co-owner John Avelluto’s trompe l’oeil paintings? Yes. No. More vino!

owlshead3.jpg


Runner Up: Crave
(570 Henry St, Carroll Gardens)
Sure, it's a great little place to stop for a pre-pizza glass of wine while you wait for a table at nearby Lucali, but it's destination-worthy for its carefully curated list of wines from around the globe, with a focuse on organic, biodynamic and energy-efficient vineyards.

crave_bw.jpg

Best Garden:

Maracuja Bar & Grill

(279 Grand St, Williamsburg)
Through the dark bar is known for its killer cheesesteaks, its jewel box of a garden comes as a surprise. Trailing ivy and small trees provide a canopy of leaves; it’s most charming when the colorful Christmas lights and lanterns are twinkling and the climbing roses are in bloom.

0205.jpg

0201.jpg

0203.jpg


Runner Up: One Last Shag
(348 Franklin Ave, Bed-Stuy)
The retro-kitschy interior evokes the trickle-down luxury of a Florida motel circa the Kennedy administration, so you may as well take your frozen margarita out to the beach—that is, the backyard, complete with bamboo tiki bar and enough sand to roll your cuffs up for. There’s usually a grill going on weekend afternoons come summer, bringing an all-inclusive crowd.

one_last_shag_bw.jpg

Best View:

Berry Park
(4 Berry St, Williamsburg)
The blocks of low-slung warehouses between McCarren Park and the waterfront—and the parks breaking up the developments along Kent Avenue’s Gold Coast—mean that Berry Park’s roof deck offers spectacular Manhattan skyline view unimpeded by gentrification (unless you count the well-dressed throngs sitting at all the tables).

berrypark.jpg


Runner Up: : B61
(187 Columbia St, Columbia Waterfront District)
When the street construction outside is finally over, the windows behind the bar at the bus line’s namesake watering hole will again provide the perfect frame for the Lower Manhattan skyline. Until then, the more immediately striking rooftop vantage from the Mexican restaurant upstairs, Alma, will do.

B61_bw.jpg

Best Spirits:

Noorman’s Kil
(609 Grand St, Williamsburg)
The selection here encompasses close to 300 whiskies, from new-crafts-movement small-batch local stuff to enough imported Scotch to have your dad’s weekly tasting club murmuring “peaty” for months. Soak it all up with a grilled cheese sandwich, if you must.(Photos Cody Swanson)

10191110600_1-copy.jpg

10191110610-copy.jpg


Runner Up: The Shanty
(79 Richardson St, Williamsburg)
The New York Distilling Company’s bar offers two of their distinct gins alongside an expertly selected and mixed collection of booze; by this time next year the Shanty hopes to be pouring their own rye as well. (Photo Cody Swanson)

shanty.jpg

Best Free Drunk Snacks:

Fourth Avenue Pub

(76 Fourth Ave, Boerum Hill)
We break our vegan vows at least once a week after we’ve had a few too many here: we grab a plastic tray, cover it with wax paper, and dump in shovelfuls of warm, buttery popcorn from the movie theater-style popcorn machine—then we shovel it up into our mouths in sloppy, embarrassing handfuls, and stumble back for more. Sorry to anyone who’s ever had to watch us do this; to the staff; and to the cows whose milk went into the butter.

Picture-188.jpg


Runner Up: Alligator Lounge
(600 Metropolitan Ave, Williamsburg)
1. Buy a beer. 2. Receive ticket. 3. Pick your way past frat boys singing along to “Living on a Prayer” as it plays from the digital jukebox. 4. Arrive at pizza oven in back of bar, where several eternally patient and humble kitchen drones constantly removing plate-sized cheese pizzas from oven. 6. Hand over ticket. 7. Receive pizza. 8. Repeat.

alligator2.jpg

Best Karaoke Night:

Pine Box Rock Shop
(12 Grattan St, Bushwick)
Aside from their wild cocktails, vegan empanadas and usual crowd of dogs and dog-lovers, Pine Box Rock Shop does an appropriately indie-skewing karaoke night. Thursdays are the perfect opportunity for Brooklyn’s shower-singers to let loose without having to venture into the expensive clusterfuck that is K-Town.

IMG_8260.jpg


Runner Up: Hope & Anchor, 

(347 Van Brunt St, Red Hook)
Sometimes it's uncomfortable to sing karaoke when everybody else doing it is, like, real singers and shit. But the crew that runs this weekend-long karaoke (usually in drag, with intimidatingly good voices) is super-friendly, as is the crowd, which will appreciate a well rehearsed duet as much as your pitchy but sincere debut.

bw2.jpg

Best Dance Night:

Tandem

(236 Troutman St, Bushwick)
Tandem might look like a mellow bar in the heart of gentrified Bushwick, but its back room serves as the perfect simulation of a Eurotrash club scene. Not knowing what you’re getting into until you step inside (while temporarily blinded by smoke machine fog) makes it more fun. (Photos by Samantha Sutcliffe)

tandem5.jpg

tandem.jpg

_DSC5670.jpg


Runner Up: Metropolitan (559 Lorimer St, Williamsburg)
This gay bar has the hottest Bresbian (Brooklyn lesbian) Wednesday night dance parties this side of the Mississippi. Still, the local community board wants to take away the bar's liquor license if party-goers keep making too much noise and, allegedly, peeing on the sidewalk.

metropolitan_bw2.jpg

Best Quiz Night:

Rocky O’Sullivan’s

(34 Van Dyke St, Red Hook)
Theme nights, music rounds and picture rounds have turned Thursday nights at Rocky’s into a Red Hook institution. After each round comes a solo question—trivia fanatics fight their answer to the front in hopes of a free pint, a mix CD of the music round and various other random prizes (we’ve gone home with a way-too-small Stephen Colbert shirt). The winning team gets a round of drinks.

rockysullivansquiz5color.jpg


Runner Up: The Sackett
(661 Sackett St, Gowanus)
Trivia aficionado Quizmaster Dave Scher leads a well-planned evening of general knowledge trivia, which occasionally means spelling Iceland’s Eyjafjallajökull volcano. Current events are definitely a focus, so pick up a Times on the way over and vie for a free bar tab.

sakett2.jpg


Best Home Office:

61 Local
(61 Bergen St, Cobble Hill)
Working at a picnic table in this high-ceilinged space, with the sun shining through skylights overhead, is the next best thing to working outside. Creature comforts include well-crafted cappuccinos, great sandwiches and a solid beer selection. Just be sure to charge up your laptop beforehand—they’re a bit short on outlets.

61local.jpg


Runner Up:South 4th Bar and Cafe (90 South 4th St, Williamsburg)
Open from seven in the morning until last call, and serving the full complement of uppers (caffeine), downers (booze) and fuel (a menu of café staples), this neighborhood spot has everything except a compelling reason to leave. Plus it’s dog-friendly.

7southfourthbarcafe_bw.jpg

Best Bar to Bring a Parent:

The Bourgeois Pig
(387 Court St, Carroll Gardens)
With gold filigree on the ceiling and every other surface swathed in brocade, the décor here is over-the-top. Whether she reads it as classy or ironic, your mom will love the Fleur De Florence, a champagne cocktail with tea syrup and black walnut bitters. (Photo by Katie Sokoler via Gothamist)

jan411bp2.jpg

jan411bp3.jpg

Best Bar to Bring a Book:

Harefield Road
(769 Metropolitan Ave, East Williamsburg)
With a wide selection of beers, and comparably great nibbles, you’ve reason aplenty to drink here. And the lighting, layout and seating are just ample enough to bar down or nook up with a buzz and a book. Until someone lures you into conversing, perhaps. And we all know where conversations about books can go. Sometimes. Choose titles accordingly if that’s your angle.(Photos by Guang Xu)

harefieldroad.jpg

harefieldroad2.jpg

Runner Up: Three Jolly Pigeons
(6802 Third Ave, Bay Ridge)

As long as it's not karaoke night (approach Fridays with caution), you can often find us in this local, plowing our way through some thin volume of buzzy contemporary lit. The well whiskey is super cheap, the lighting low but not punishingly dim, and the mood laid-back—it's as easy to join a conversation as it is to be left alone. (There might be some classic rock on in the background, but you've learned how to filter out classic rock, haven't you?) Even though some Bay Ridge smart aleck in the recent "Shit People from Brooklyn Say" said that only hipsters read books in bars—he was in front of Kettle Black, which is safely on the other end of town—no one here has ever even cocked a brow in our direction for burying our nose in the pages of some book.
bw.jpg

Best Bar to Bring a Date:

Wolf and Deer

(74 Fifth Ave, Park Slope)
The cozy space is hiply rustic, the music is pleasantly inoffensive dinner-party worldbeat, the wine is varied and reasonably priced, and the charcuterie and cheese plates are small but luxuriant. If things don’t go well, it wasn’t meant to be. (Photos by Cody Swanson)

0922119470-copy.jpg

0922119463-copy.jpg

0922119481-copy.jpg


Runner Up: Way
Station
(683 Washington Ave, Prospect Heights)
Plenty other bars have similar red leather banquettes and burnished lighting. But Way Station has a TARDIS. Like, from Dr. Who. Nerds like to bone too, you know! And a bar with an actual TARDIS is like Nerd Spanish Fly.

waystation_bw.jpg

Best Local:
Sunny’s


 (253 Conover St, Red Hook)
Miles from the subway and closed more than it’s open, Sunny’s sits near the waterfront on a desolate stretch of Belgian-blocked street—where it has, under various names, for the last 120 years. Its rickety, homespun interior is the model for what every hipster bar in Brooklyn wants to be, except it’s totally unforced. Sunny’s doesn’t try to be the borough’s best local bar. It just is.

3825421878_dd88af6477_new.jpg


Runner Up: Fulton Grand
(1011 Fulton St, Clinton Hill)
The best bar at which to do shots with the bartender at four in the afternoon the day before Christmas is, of course, whichever bar happens to be the nearby place you regularly end up at by default at slow hours. But if that bar is Fulton Grand, how very lucky for you, not least because you’ll never be able to find that Elliott Gould Jim Beam ad for your own living room.

bw.jpg

Comments (9)

Showing 1-9 of 9

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-9 of 9

Add a comment

Readers also liked…

Popular Events

More by The Editors

Latest in Features

© 2013 The L Magazine
Website powered by Foundation