Bloomberg's New E-Cigarette Ban Is A Terrible Idea

08/09/2013 1:19 PM |


Granted, I’m a pretty textbook big-government, nanny-state liberal, and vocally on-record as being in favor of most of Bloomberg’s bans (as well as a few hypothetical ones). But this news, via Gothamist, that he’s trying to sneak what would essentially be a full-scale ban on electronic cigarettes into new tobacco legislation? Not great.


And probably easy enough for people to ignore, given that electronic cigarettes are still finding their footing in the market, and it’s part of a bill (currently being considered by the City Council) that would do legitimately good things for smoking prevention, like raising the smoking age to 21 and prohibiting cigarette coupons. Still, the quiet provision that flavored e-cigarettes be sold only in elusive “tobacco bars” would be a fairly crushing blow not just to the industry, but to the scores of people using them as a relatively healthy (“relatively” is key here) way to wean themselves off of regular cigarettes.

One public health expert who spoke with the site put it more bluntly: “This is a de facto ban on electronic cigarettes. Pretty much all electronic cigarettes are flavored; they’re essentially flavored products. You’re basically telling a bunch of ex-smokers to go back to cigarettes […] [Electronic-cigarettes] are a product that’s literally saving people’s lives, people who are literally at risk of disease and death, and giving them an alternative. What are these people gonna do?”

The mayor’s office and the health department have yet to comment on this, but the bill cites research indicating that there’s been an uptick in high schoolers who report having “tried” e-smokes in the past year, which makes sense, given the degree to which they’ve exploded onto the market. Experts dispute their popularity among teenagers, and anecdotally, it’s pretty safe to say that no one (not even—or especially not—Stephen Dorff) looks cool enough smoking these that any innocent non-smoker is going to see them and say “whoa, that’s the social crutch I’ve been looking for.” It’s not going to happen. What has happened—again, anecdotally—is a lot of smokers have used these things to cut way, way back on far more dangerous methods of taking in nicotine. It’s not ideal, of course, but it’s a start, and maybe worth putting a little research into the longer-term costs and benefits before banning them outright. Of all the important causes one could take up in the last few months as one of the most powerful political figures in the entire U.S.—like putting an end to stop and frisk or making sure your citizens are earning a living wage—this doesn’t need to be one of them.

Follow Virginia K. Smith on Twitter @vksmith.

6 Comment

  • This document has audio recordings of NYC Politicians lying to e-cigarette users at a NYC Health Committee hearing:

  • “It’s not ideal, of course, …”

    How are e-cigarettes not ideal? I guess that statement assumes that the nicotine is a problem, but is it? Why do we assume that getting nicotine from a Nicorette is OK and not a problem but getting nicotine from an e-cigarette is a problem and not “ideal”.

    In fact e-cigarettes are ideal because …

    1) Nobody has a cogent argument as to why ingesting nicotine is bad.
    What is the problem with being addicted to nicotine as compared to say caffeine?
    2) Zero impact on others.
    3) No known long-term health effects on the user.
    4) No cogent arguments or evidence that vaping e-cigarettes leads to other
    health affecting behaviours like smoking.

    Anyway, I don’t understand why they are seen as not ideal.

  • Im tired of hearing about this stuff. E Cigs have saved my mothers life, she went from 2-3 packs a day heavy smoking addiction chain smoking all day. Doctor said she would die if she didnt stop in a few years and she picked up a e cig. She has been smoke free for 3 months. her coughing has gone down so much and she doesnt have problems walking. quit messing with e cigs please! and about the flavors who wants to smoke e cigs flavored with smoke? really?

  • heres the documented proof ecigs are as safe as eating most foods:…

    Welcome to Larry’s e Liquids. I was a 35 year smoker. I was introduced to electronic cigarettes about 2 years ago. Like you, I have tried every kind of e-cigarette available such as: Eon Smoke
    Green Smoke Blu Cigs V2 Logics The first problem I experienced was the bad chemical taste. After doing a little research, I found out the reason for this bad taste is because these cigarettes are made in China. After finding that out, I started buying American made e-liquid. Soon I started making my own American made e-liquid.After solving the taste problem, I started noticing that the e-cigarettes that I bought from the stores were very poorly made with little to no quality control. I spent hundreds of dollars on these toys. I started doing hours and hours of research again and discovered that most of the e-cig companies paid a lot for marketing and pennies for the actual manufacturing of the product.It really annoyed me that after trying all of these different e-cig products, either the product did not give me a good throat hit or the amount of vapor that I was inhaling was nothing like taking a hit from a real cigarette. They just weren’t satisfying enough to switch to permanently.
    After switching from e-cig to e-cig to find the perfect one, I found a couple manufacturers such as Kanger and Smoktech that were actually well made and were satisfying, but the units were too big and bulky. BaCK to the computer to google some more and finally…….I found it – the e-cig that I have been searching for everywhere. A high quality e-cig that performs like the big bulky units but smaller and lighter. After several months of vaping this unit, I was hooked. I was so hooked that I bought this e-cigarette in bulk and started distributing it. If you live in the Brooklyn, Queens or NYC area, you can be vaping with the best product on the market today in 3-5 hours. That’s right. I love this product so much I will personally BRING it to you, fill you up with whatever liquid you like and let you try it out. If you buy this product straight from the manufacturer you will pay $65 for 2 e-cigs and TRITON kits (includes a battery, clearmiser tank and charger), $25 for the liquid and $10 for shipping – a total of $95. I will give you all this and…..a bottle of Larrys e Liquids for $45 this price includes free delivery